ad

Comprehensive Unity: The No Anglican Covenant Blog

Wednesday, July 13, 2011

A really good post on Autonomy

Here is a very well done post on the history and value of provincial autonomy. This will probably be added to our website too. You will want to read and comment on it I think.

FWIW
jimB

Note: The article by the Rev. Canon Alan T. Perry has now been added to the No Anglican Covenant Web site’s Resources page. You can find it here.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Cross Posted From OCICW

Accompanied by this brilliant cartoon he drew for it, MadPriest published this as a guest post a few days ago.  I hope you find it interesting.

FWIW
jimB




GROUPTHINK AND COURAGE
A GUEST POST BY JIMB
After the debacle in Vietnam, Bill Moyers wrote an interesting and introspective analysis of the White House decision-making culture. The need to be in the group, to be a part of the culture and not be a problem for it, overrode judgement. Even though White House staff individually knew the bombing campaign against North Vietnam simply was not working, the need to be part of the inner circle led to recommendations for more bombs. The ongoing deaths of US military personnel and Vietnamese civilians did not move them to change tactics.

When anyone finally broke ranks, resigned and said what everyone else knew, that the bombing was not working, the members of the group found it easier to attack that person than to face the facts.

Which leads me to think of two groups. One group is very small and prophetic; the other is steadfastly loyal to the inner circle.

Two English bishops have become Episcopal Patrons of the No Anglican Covenant Coalition, placing themselves outside the circle of institutional Covenant supporters. (See link.) Bishops Saxbee and Selby are now at risk of being slurred and isolated. Their action took courage. We also know that several of our brave clerics have given up any hope of advancement to the House of Bishops by being in the Coalition.

Groupthink mentality is very hard to escape. Moyers is a powerful intellect, and even he was not able to do so for quite a while. So the persistence of other group, the Lambeth staff, English House of Bishops, and the lay leadership that continues to promote the Covenant, is hardly surprising. We hear that there are members who know the Covenant is a multi-dimensional failure. They know it won't be universally adopted and will not therefore bring the Communion together, let alone keep it together. The covenanted Church will become hugely litigious. But they do not speak up; they do not resign. They stay in the inner circle. It is safer there. The group thinks well of them.

Jesus was not an insider. He did not take the safe path. He demanded justice from the powerful. Likewise, Nathan demanded justice from David. Throughout the Hebrew Scriptures, it is those who demanded justice who are remembered as prophets, those who spoke for God. When Jesus is recognized as a prophet in the Gospels, it is because he calls for justice and does not bow to mere rulers. Do I think I know two prophetic bishops? Yes. Do I know some prophetic priests? Yes.

It is difficult to fault those who stay in the circle of power. After all, they are doing their jobs and supporting their archbishops. But it is relevant to note that history has sided against every single point made by those who called the first Lambeth Conference intending to rebuke a prophetic bishop. History largely forgets those who play it safe. For those in the inner circle, for the archbishops who demand yes men and women, that is something to think about.

FWIW
jimB

Labels:

Wednesday, July 6, 2011

Coalition Appoints Episcopal Patrons

NEWS RELEASE
JULY 6, 2011
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE


BISHOPS JOHN SAXBEE, PETER SELBY TO BE PATRONS OF NO ANGLICAN COVENANT COALITION

LONDON – The Right Reverend Dr John Saxbee and the Right Reverend Dr Peter Selby have been appointed Episcopal Patrons of the international No Anglican Covenant Coalition.

“The Anglican Communion doesn’t need a Covenant because Anglicanism is a Covenant, predicated on grace and goodwill,” Dr Saxbee said. “If there is grace and goodwill, a Covenant is unnecessary. If there is no grace or goodwill, a Covenant will be unavailing.” Dr Saxbee was Bishop of Lincoln from 2001 until his retirement in January of this year.

Dr Selby, Bishop of Worcester from 1997 to 2007, has been a supporter of the Coalition since its launch last November. “This proposed Covenant is not the solution to the tensions in the Anglican Communion,” he said. “It will inevitably create a litigious Communion where every serious disagreement will become a possible occasion to seek a province’s exclusion.”

“More and more questions are being raised about the potential pitfalls of the proposed Anglican Covenant,” said the Reverend Dr Lesley Fellows, Moderator of the No Anglican Covenant Coalition. “We have consistently seen that support for the Covenant tends to collapse in the face of full and fair discussion and analysis. We are very pleased to welcome Bishops Selby and Saxbee as our first Episcopal Patrons. They are well respected in the Church of England and throughout the Anglican Communion. We expect that their views on the Covenant will persuade many more people to take a harder look at the risks inherent in this radical proposal.”

-30-

A PDF version of the above announcement can be found here.

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

Blame Canada?

On his very good blog site, Coalition member The Rev'd Canon Alan Perry has written a response to The Rev'd Canon Dr. Barnett-Cowan's Living Church article. It is very much worthy of your time.

The Rev'd Canon Dr Alyson Barnett-Cowan, Director for Unity, Faith and Order for the Anglican Communion, has written a defence of the proposed Anglican Covenant. If I am reading her correctly, she is suggesting that this document is just a natural development in a series of events that began nearly a century and a half ago at the instigation of the Canadian Church.

Read it all here: Canon Alan's Blog

Labels:

Monday, July 4, 2011

Another Voice Heard From

"Integrity President Caro Hall reflects on Independence Day 2011"

... I think The Episcopal Church (TEC) has been in a similar state of ambivalence when it comes to the Anglican Covenant. But the recently published report of the Standing Commission on Constitution and Canons (SCCC) has changed the whole picture...

Read it all at: walking with integrity

Labels:

Saturday, June 25, 2011

News Flash

The Executive Council has reversed its position and released the working report on constitutional issues regarding the covenant. HT to the Lead which has the article here.

Labels:

Sunday, June 19, 2011

Central New York's Response to the "covenant"

This was recently released. It was signed by the entire deputation. I have reproduced it exactly as I received it.
Easter Sunday 2011


To Mrs. Bonnie Anderson President of the House of Deputies, The Most Rev. Katharine Jefforts Schori, Presiding Bishop, and our Brothers and Sisters of the Executive Council of The Episcopal Church:


The Deputation to the 77th General Convention from the Diocese of Central New York has prayerfully and thoughtfully considered the Final Draft of the Anglican Communion Covenant. Informed by study and prayer as well as comments received from individuals and parishes from our diocese we find ourselves of one mind on this matter.


Like many across our Church we treasure our identity as Anglicans, respect and hold in esteem the See of Canterbury, and find ourselves strengthened by the relationships and ministries of our brothers and sisters throughout the Anglican Communion. We rejoice that many of the relationships have continued to deepen over the past eight years even as we have lamented the many areas of conflict that exist within our Communion. While we support in principle any efforts to strengthen the bonds of affection that we share and the mission and ministry that we offer in Christ’s name, we are clear that any such actions must allow us to move together mitigating future conflict to the extent possible.


Sections One, Two and Three of the Final Draft of the Anglican Communion Covenant beautifully articulates some of our most cherished values for living faithfully as a Communion. Regrettably we find that Section Four: Our Covenanted Life Together, is not in keeping with our understanding of a life-giving covenant. This is gravely unfortunate because it is our life together that most concerns us. We are troubled by the punitive nature of this section and find that instead of providing for an opportunity to strengthen our common life, it presumes failure in covenant keeping. We believe that grace can abound in covenanted relationships but with Section Four we are unable to joyfully bind ourselves to these agreements. Its inclusion in this Final Draft presses us to reject the document entirely.


We have not arrived at this decision lightly. We hold out hope that the conversations that have developed during these years of heightened conflict will continue as we seek God’s will for us as a Communion. As one parish reflected at the conclusion of their study process, we want to remain “vigilant for the opportunities that will surely present themselves for accommodation and assimilation of the current sources of conflict into an evolving and strengthened [C]ommunion.”


As people of resurrection hope and promise we believe that God has not brought us thus far to abandon us. To the contrary, it is our fervent prayer that God still has use for the Anglican Communion with a future that includes The Episcopal Church. This future, however must be one that honors the varying histories, polities, cultures, and customs found within our beloved Communion. Though we cannot accept this Anglican Communion Covenant in its current form, we offer our continued prayers, presence, and open and discerning hearts as we move forward into the future God intends for us.


Faithfully,


The Deputation to the 77th General Convention from the Diocese of Central New York

Labels: