ad

Comprehensive Unity: The No Anglican Covenant Blog

Wednesday, August 31, 2011

Coalition Sees Pattern in Oxford Introduction

In the previous post, I discussed the deficiencies of “Introduction to the Anglican Covenant Debate,” a two-page document prepared for the Diocese of Oxford by Canon John Rees. The No Anglican Covenant has now issued a statement about “Introduction” and a news release discussing the statement.

The Coalition expresses disappointment with “Introduction,” but it also sees a pattern in its approach. Here is a paragraph from “Statement from the No Anglican Covenant Coalition Regarding Covenant Background Information Prepared for the Diocese of Oxford”:
The Oxford document is consistent with the general approach to promoting the Anglican Covenant in the Church of England by downplaying its significance while claiming that the survival of the Anglican Communion depends on its adoption. While the Church of England is preoccupied with issues such as women bishops, there is a serious risk that the Anglican Covenant will be adopted without adequate or informed debate about the document and the implications of its centralisation for the Church of England and the Anglican Communion. The consistent and erroneous depiction of the Anglican Covenant as largely meaningless and harmless only increases this risk. Comparable tactics were on display a few months ago in the Diocese of Lichfield, where pro-Covenant presenters were given extensive time to sell the Covenant prior to a short debate with alternating pro- and anti-Covenant speakers.
Read both the statement and news release in their entirety. The statement can be found on the Resources page of the Coalition’s Web site here. The news release can be found on the same page here.

Labels: , , , , ,

Thursday, August 25, 2011

Oxford Diocese Intro Downplays Covenant

The Diocese of Oxford recently placed the two-page “Introduction to the Anglican Covenant Debate” on its Web site. The document is intended to inform the discussion about the Anglican Covenant that will be held by the Diocesan Synod. (The document has been added to the Resources page of the No Anglican Covenant Coalition Web site.)

The document, written by Canon John Rees, is a great disappointment. Being as short as it is, of course, it can hardly be comprehensive. It suffers from two more significant problems, however. First, it downplays the significance of the Covenant decision, saying little about Covenant controversies or even suggesting that the decision is a momentous one. In the main discussion, the only hint that there might be reasons to reject the covenant is the observation that conservatives think the disciplinary provisions too weak and liberals find them too strong. The implication seems to be that Section 4 must be about right.

The second problem with “Introduction” is its failure to point readers to a broad selection of commentary on the Covenant. Only five references are given, most of them Church of England documents that view the Covenant as an unalloyed good. Why did Rees not reference our own Resources page? (The answer, my friend, is blowin’ in the wind.) Rees did not even reference favorable material that at least tries to come to grips with objections to the Covenant.

Read the Oxford document. What do you think?

Labels: , , , ,

Thursday, August 4, 2011

Episcopal Church in the Philippines Rejects Covenant

George Conger, in a story for The Church of England Newspaper, reports that the bishops of the Episcopal Church in the Philippines have voted not to adopt the Anglican Covenant. The basis of the story appears to be the 2nd Quarter 2011 issue of The Philippine Episcopalian.

The Episcopal Church in the Philippines thus becomes the first church of the Anglican Communion to reject the Covenant outright.

Labels: ,

Friday, July 29, 2011

Ooops! An Apology

In addition to this blog which is dedicated to a very specific topic, I like most of the other members of the Coalition, operate my own blog. Because I do some of the maintenance on this blog, mine is close to this one.

Inadvertently, I posted here a comment on American politics that is rather far from the topic of the Covenant. I have taken down that post but I did not notice right away and it lived in cyberspace long enough to proliferate.

If you saw it, and felt it did not fit, you were correct and I deeply apologize. The post actually makes some sense on my personal blog and I will re-post it there soon. In the meaintime I apologize and hope you will accept my assurance that this was an error and neither I nor any member of the coalition speaks for its members on secular political subjects.

J. A. (Jim) Beyer

Friday, July 22, 2011

Easier-to-read Covenant Introduction

When the No Anglican Covenant Coalition developed “A Short Introduction to the Anglican Covenant,” we worked hard to fit everything onto one page. (See “Coalition Publishes One-Page Covenant Introduction.”) The objective was not only to create a more balanced introduction than was available from official sources, but to produce a convenient handout for groups discussing the Covenant. That the resulting documents were less than elegant was the price that had to be paid for fitting everything on one page.

In response to complaints that “A Short Introduction” could benefit from being more attractive, we decided to offer the same text as a prettier and more readable two-page document. Such a document can still be distributed as a one-sheet handout, of course, if the text is printed on both sides of the paper.

The two-page version of “A Short Introduction to the Anglican Covenant” is available as a PDF file formatted for A4 or letter-size paper.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Coalition Publishes One-Page Covenant Introduction

The No Anglican Covenant Coalition has today published a one-page handout titled “A Short Introduction to the Anglican Covenant.” The document is intended to provide a brief but useful view of the Covenant for those unfamiliar with it. It describes the Covenant, explains where it came from, and offers an evaluation of its possible effect. Anglicans around the world are encouraged to download “A Short Introduction” and to use it to educate their fellow Anglicans.

A news release about the new handout can be found here. A letter-size version of “A Short Introduction” is available here and an A4 version is available here.


A Short Introduction to the Anglican Covenant

Labels: ,

Friday, July 15, 2011

Where are the best arguments for the Anglican Covenant?

The No Anglican Covenant Coalition has built a large collection of material about the Anglican Covenant. The largest segment of this compilation is of essays opposing adoption of the pact. In fact, there seems to be a dearth of argumentation on the other side, and much of what there is comes from Lambeth Palace, the Anglican Communion Office, or people who have had a direct role in producing the Covenant text.

Although there have been many reasons advanced for scrapping the Covenant, reasons that have been carefully laid out and fully explored, arguments for the Covenant seem to rely on the notion that no one can think of anything else—the Covenant is the only way forward we are told—or on what can only be called naïve hopefulness.

Perhaps Covenant opponents are missing something. Perhaps there are compelling arguments in favor of Covenant adoption that have received little publicity or are hiding in obscure corners of the World Wide Web.

So here is a challenge, one tossed out to Covenant supporters and detractors alike: What do you think are the strongest arguments in favor of the Covenant, and where can the best articulation of those arguments be found?

We will even offer a prize for the best entry. For the person identifying the most compelling defense of the Covenant, we will give you one day to write anything you want concerning the Covenant on this blog (consistent with good taste) and reference your material on Facebook as well.

Please answer in a comment, and include appropriate links.

Labels: ,