ad

Comprehensive Unity: The No Anglican Covenant Blog

Monday, October 22, 2012

Blog Comments

Recently, this blog has experienced some odd posts. While I share this blog with my colleagues and do not post my "three rules" here regularly, they are worthy of your consideration.

  1. Stay within musket range of the topic. Items that are off subject are deleted.
  2. Ad hominem attacks will be deleted period.
  3. Avoid obscure unintelligible writing. While this is often in the eye of the beholder, Lionel and I while tolerant, do mean it.
So, if you are wondering why you are not finding some brilliant comment you think really showed the Coalition how wrong it is, consider it it light of those three. We do not claim infallibility, we know we can be wrong. But we do expect guests here to be reasonably polite.


Jim B

Labels: ,

Sunday, August 12, 2012

General Convention Brochure

The No Anglican Covenant Coalition distributed both buttons and brochures at the recent General Convention. For the benefit of those who did not attend, you can see one of our buttons in a previous post.

Our brochure was a tri-fold affair on glossy white paper:


Click here to see the content of the brochure, which was designed specifically for distribution at the 2012 General Convention.

You can find pictures of Malcolm French and me at our General Convention display on my own blog.

Labels: , , ,

Sunday, August 5, 2012

What Would an Ideal Anglican Communion Look Like?

The Anglican Covenant would re-engineer the Anglican Communion. But the Anglican Communion was never really engineered to begin with. Instead, it developed in fits and starts with no planning as to what a “mature” Anglican Communion should look like.

Encouraging the Communion to avoid making the serious mistake of adopting the proposed Anglican Covenant has been satisfying, but Anglicans really should be asking what an ideal Anglican Communion would look like. What would we want to create if we were beginning from scratch?

Do readers have any ideas to contribute? What should be the underlying principles of an ideal Anglican Communion? How should those principles be incorporated into particular structures and processes?

Labels:

Wednesday, July 11, 2012

ACANZAP says NO, TEC declines to take position

NEWS RELEASE
JULY 11, 2012
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

COALITION STATEMENT ON THIS WEEK’S VOTES ON THE ANGLICAN COVENANT

INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA – Two days ago, the Anglican Church in Aotearoa, New Zealand and Polynesia rejected the Anglican Covenant. Yesterday, the Episcopal Church voted to “decline to take a position on the Anglican Covenant,” and to continue to monitor the progress of the Covenant until the next General Convention in 2015. No Anglican Covenant Moderator, the Rev. Malcolm French, has issued the following statement:

The wind has clearly gone out of the sails of the Anglican Covenant. There was not even a single dissenting vote when the Anglican Church in Aotearoa, New Zealand and Polynesia declared itself unable to adopt the Covenant. While our Coalition would have preferred a clearer “no” from the Episcopal Church, the resolution passed in Indianapolis is scarcely more than an abstention – and the commitment to “monitor the ongoing developments” rings hollow when we consider that the same General Convention phased out funding for the Episcopal Church staff position for Anglican Communion affairs. Perhaps they will monitor the situation by following #noanglicancovenant on Twitter.

The next major step in the Covenant process will be at the Anglican Consultative Council meeting in Auckland, New Zealand, this fall. We understand that there will be an attempt to introduce a ratification threshold and a sunset date to the Covenant process. Depending on the details, our Coalition is likely to be broadly supportive of both initiatives.

-30-

The No Anglican Covenant Coalition is an international group of Anglicans concerned about how the proposed Anglican Covenant would radically change the nature of the Anglican Communion.

noanglicancovenant.org

The Rev. Malcolm French (Canada)     +1-306-550-2277
The Rev. Jean Mayland (England)    +44 07966 921247
The Ven. Lawrence Kimberley (New Zealand)     +64 3 981 7384
The Rev. Canon Hugh Magee (Scotland)     +44 1334 470446
Dr. Lionel Deimel (USA)     +1-412-512-9087


Note: A PDF version of this news release is available here.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Episcopal Church House of Deputies Passes Substitute Covenant Resolution

Just a little while ago, the House of Deputies of the Episcopal Church General Convention passed a revised version of Resolution B005. The resolution states that the church is too divided to made a decision on the Anglican Covenant now and asks for yet another task force on the Covenant to report to the General Convention in 2015. An amendment was defeated that would have removed both provisions about being divided and about creating a task force. When it came time to speak to the resolution itself, which the No Anglican Covenant Coalition opposed, five speakers had spoken in favor of B005 and none against when the question was called. Three of the speakers were from the committee that drafted the substitute resolution. Before the actual vote, one deputy expressed disappointment that no dissenting voices had been heard.

A voice vote only was taken. The ayes were in the majority, but, I think, not by much. It is not at all clear that the will of the majority has been served.

The resolution now goes to the House of Bishops, where passage seems likely, but by no means is a sure thing.

Labels: ,

Monday, July 9, 2012

A clear "NO!" from Aotearoa

A report from the Anglican Church in Aotearoa, New Zealand and Polynesia.

ACANZP has
"rejected the proposed Covenant
based on section 4,
but ... subscribed to 1, 2 and 3
as a useful starting point
for consideration of our Anglican understanding of the church.

We have also affirmed
the commitment of the ACANZP to the Communion
and the Instruments,
and to using procedures
similar to those in Section 3
if another church raises concerns
about what we are doing or going to do.

The whole motion has been passed in open Synod,
with no negative voice."


Official text and links to follow once we have it. No Anglican Covenant Coalition Moderator Malcolm French and the Coalition's Episcopal Church Convenor Lionel Deimel are both blogging regularly (ie, more or less daily) about the state of the Covenant debate at the Episcopal Church's 77th General Convention.

Saturday, July 7, 2012

Why Not “Maybe”?

The essay below was published today in Issues 2012, a  newsletter distributed by the Consultation at General Convention.

Many deputies are wearing “Yes to Communion/No to Covenant” buttons. Meanwhile, the legislative subcommittee dealing with the Anglican Covenant, chaired by the Rev. Mark Harris, is considering advancing two resolutions, one expressing the church’s commitment to the Anglican Communion and the other saying neither “yes” nor “no” to the Covenant. The first resolution is likely to pass easily; no one is calling for The Episcopal Church to withdraw from the Anglican Communion. A resolution that somehow says “maybe” (or “not now” or “not this one”), however, is not only a bad idea, but a resolution that will invite spirited and possibly divisive debate.

Why is saying “maybe” to the Covenant not a good option? Quite simply, Episcopalians have never wanted a covenant and have no desire to surrender their church’s autonomy to centralized Anglican bodies that include representatives of churches whose theological, ecclesiastical, and moral proclivities differ radically from theirs. Historical ties—often very tenuous ones—do not justify such a surrender to a future Anglican magisterium, which would be the ultimate effect of Covenant adoption.

Episcopalians are understandably queasy about what they should do about the Covenant. They realize that its origin is in the reactionary response to non-“traditional” actions by our church, and they are loath to be seen as defensive or disrespectful of churches in former colonial nations. In short, we don’t like to say “no,” so we accepted the Windsor Report with some grace and passed 2006-B033, though with reluctance and without enthusiasm.

If no church had yet rejected the Covenant, we might do well to defer, as we would indeed seem reactive. But England has rejected the Covenant, rumors to the contrary notwithstanding; Scotland trounced a resolution to adopt the Covenant; New Zealand will likely vote it down; and Australia will almost assuredly be unable to adopt it. It is time for The Episcopal Church to say that the Covenant is a bad idea—indeed, and un-Anglican idea—badly implemented, and one that must be discarded quickly if the Communion is to move forward as an effective instrument of mission and not simply a venue for endless and divisive disputes.

We should say “no” to the Anglican Covenant; not only for our own sake, but for the sake of the Communion. “Maybe” is not good enough.

Lionel Deimel, No Anglican Covenant Coalition

Labels: , , ,